The Wrong Questions
The Wrong Questions, AKA The Facebook “Producer”
I post some of my screenwriting info about classes and such on Facebook in a couple screenwriting groups. The screenwriting groups have really scattered membership. Some people there are new and just learning. Some are old pros who stop in to answer some questions. Some are predators who are really there looking for free material from inexperienced writers in exchange for fueling the dream. The group members are an interesting mix.
I post about a flash sale for classes. Someone shows and says in a sort of belligerent way, What are your credits? I post the bio from my site and a couple details and say I’m on IMBDB if they want to look me up.
They won’t find much there because an IMDB listing means you one, worked on a project that got greenlit and went to production and got released and two, got screen credit on that project. So whether or not you have a lot of IMDB listings isn’t really reflective of how much work you’ve done professionally in the industry. But that sounds like what he is (sort of belligerently) asking for. Then he comes back and says there are 14 Max Adams on IMDB (whoah, really?, there used to just be about four of us), give him a link. Still sort of belligerently. Jeez. So I tell him my middle initial and a title.
But I’m thinking, the whole time that is going down, What are you looking for here? Are you looking to hire a writer? Because these are “I’m looking to hire a writer” questions and unless you’ve got a budget and premise and project and know my quote and understand how the industry works and want to talk about projects I’ve worked on, not just screen credits, and people I’ve worked with, maybe these are the wrong questions and this is the wrong conversation.
See —
In terms of looking for a writing teacher? He was asking the wrong questions.
He wanted a passel of produced titles with screen credit. Which doesn’t really tell you, one, how much work someone has done professionally in the industry, or two, whether the person is a good teacher who can give you knowledge and craft tools that will make your writing stronger.
There is a big difference between being a good writer and being a good teacher. One of the best teachers I ever had was Shine Graham. She taught a lit class at Orange Coast College that was amazing. I learned a ton. And we had this conversation one time, in which I said I was writing, and she said, That is amazing and so brave, I would never try to write.
I was gob smacked because Shine Graham was so smart and knowledgeable and was teaching me so much, and — she had no desire to write. She just loved studying great writing and teaching about great writing — by other writers. She never wrote a word. Never even wanted to. I think she thought it was sort of outrageous to even think about writing when she read and studied so many of the masters she had no intention of trying to emulate or cast a hat into the ring with. But she taught me so much.
Then there are people who are writing professionally in the industry, who are big names, with a whole lot of credits on screen. Some of the anointed, who always get green lights, who always get a screen credit. But. Who can’t teach. They give interesting talks. They talk about what they have done on the job and their history in the industry and it’s interesting and entertaining but —
They’re not teachers. They’re celebrity writers. With interesting stories. But they don’t know how to teach someone else how to do what they do. They can only tell you they did it. And with whom. And deliver some arresting and entertaining anecdotes about doing it along the way. But. Not how to write.
Then, and this is a real problem, there are the “teachers” who have not written professionally and don’t really know how to teach you what other people do that works writing, they are doing what I call “teaching by book.” They have read the books. They can regurgitate what the books say. And they pat you on the back for putting words on a page. Which feels good. It’s nice to get patted on the back. But they don’t know how to give you feedback or teach you how to make your writing stronger. They are just regurgitating what they have read in books and patting you on the back for putting words on a page.
You can read Save the Cat yourself and what you really need is guidance and interpretation and maybe something that isn’t in Save the Cat and other books that everyone has read that don’t really teach you much and, when you turn in words on pages, maybe you don’t just need a pat on the back, maybe you need guidance that will make you a stronger writer.
That guy asking belligerent questions about credits?
That guy was asking the wrong question.
The right questions are, How are your students and workshoppers doing? What are your students and workshoppers saying? What do they say about you? And what’s happening for them after they work with you?
If you’re a potential student considering a teacher deciding whether or not you want to work with that teacher? Don’t ask about their screen credits. Ask about their workshoppers and students.
Four of my workshoppers and students have won the Nicholl Fellowship in Screenwriting from the Academy of Motion Pictures, Arts and Sciences. Students and workshoppers have won Sundance slots, Disney fellowships, Austin Film Festival screenwriting awards. Students and workshoppers are optioned, sold, and produced.
That’s what counts. That’s what he should have been asking about.
PS: If you’d like to know what my students & workshoppers think, hit Testimonials. And if you’d like to learn more about the right way to introduce characters, check out my six week master screenwriting course Character Writing — or my screenwriting video course Character Writing.
